Menu > Archived Meetings

FACULTY SENATE MEETING MINUTES
Tuesday, September 10, 2002

The meeting was called to order by the Chair, Dr. Anne O. Kilpatrick at 7:45 AM on Tuesday, September 10, 2002 in Room 107 Admin./Library Building.

MEMBERSHIP ROSTER:

College of Medicine, Basic Sciences:

Present: Philippe Arnaud (Council Member), Sally Self and Joan Olson. (New Senator: Katherine E. Meier)
Absent: Janice Lage, Lucille London and Eberhard Voit.

College of Medicine, Clinical Sciences:

Present: Connie Best, DeAnna Cheek, Paul Gold, Subbi P. Mathur (Secretary), Benjamin Saunders, Dean Schuyler and Thomas Steele. (New Senators: Timothy W. Garvey, George M. Johnson, Dana King and Shailesh B. Patel).
Absent
: Narendra L. Banik, Timothy Carter, Gary Gilkeson, Mark Green, Barry Hainer, Terry O'Brien, Susan B. Tate (not at MUSC), Philip Saul, and Renan Uflacker.

College of Dental Medicine

Present: Luis Leite (Council Member), Stephen Malley and Peter Kobes. (New Senator: Richard J. Albenesius).
Absent
: Elizabeth Pilcher and Carlos Salinas (Alternate).

College of Health Professions:

Present: Anne Kilpatrick (Chair), and Andrea White. (New Senators: Jack K. Thomas and Jennifer Horner).
Absent
:
Richard Hernandez (not at MUSC), Janice Hundley (not at MUSC), Gail Pashek (not at MUSC)

Library Sciences and Informatics:

Present: Jennie Ariail (Parliamentarian) Mary P. Mauldin (Council Member) and Nancy McKeehan. (New Senator: Geoffrey Freeman)
Absent
:
Joann Sullivan

College of Nursing:

Present: Tara Hulsey and Francine R. Margolius (Vice Chair). (New Senators: Julia Ball, Elizabeth Erkel and John M. Welton (Alternate).
Absent
:
Ramita Bonadonna (not at MUSC).

College of Pharmacy:

Present: Katherine Chessman .(New Senators: Marc Lapointe and Kristi L. Lenz.
Absent
:
John Bosso, Joli Cerveny and Kit Simpson (Council Member).

APPROVAL OF MINUTES:

The meeting minutes of July and August 2002 were posted in the unapproved form on the web site and were available for review prior to meeting. Both the minutes were approved with minor revisions. The next meeting will be held at 7:45 AM on Tuesday, October 1, 2002 in the Admin./Library Room 107.

MEETING PROCEEDINGS:

I. Announcements by the Chair

Anne O. Kilpatrick emphasized the importance of faculty governance and cited participation by our senators in the various University-wide administrative committees. She also outlined the requirements for the office of Provost as perceived by the Search Committee for the Provost, wherein she is a member. She commended the various Senate Committees for doing an exemplary job in completing their charges.

II. Remarks by Dr. John Raymond, Interim Provost:

Dr. Raymond complemented the work done by the Faculty Senate in advancing collaboration with the Administration and educating the Faculty on Tenure and Mentoring. He emphasized the importance of balancing the three missions of the medical school namely, clinical, research and teaching. He cited the clinical mission as being the most essential function of the university. He also mentioned about revamping the University Research Council and solicited membership on this committee from the faculty senators. His comments were enthusiastically received by the Senators.

III. Committee Reports:

Governance Committee

Chair: Francine R. Margolius

Dr. Margolius commended the hard work of her committee members namely Subbi P. Mathur, Nancy McKeehan, Janice Hundley, Joli Cerveny, Betsy Pilcher, Gail Pashek and Eberhard Voit. She mentioned that all these members were ready and willing to help with the governance duties as assigned by her. She lists the following as the major committee accomplishments for the year:

Faculty Handbook: The revised Faculty Handbook will be on the web shortly and will be the contract for the faculty.

Elections: The turn over for this year's election was the highest in many years. She mentioned that the electronic voting still has some bugs that need to be cleaned out. But she was happy with the outcome of the elections and the participation of the colleges.

Academic Affairs Committee

Chair: Philippe Arnaud

Dr. Arnaud commended the hard work by his committee in identifying major issues regarding facutly compensation, including problems relating to distribution of indirect costs of grant monnies. The committee members were: Subbi P. Mathur, Barry Hainer, Paul Gold, Jennie Ariail, DeAnna Cheek, Joan Olson, Tara Hulsey, Gary Gilkeson and John Bosso. Indirect Costs Sub committee: Eberhard Voit (Chair), Gail Pashek, Narendra L. Banik, Kit Simpson, Paul Gold, Carlos Salinas and Susan Tate. The Committee is awaiting access to obtaining data on compensation from the Office of the Provost with the help of the Senate Chair. The Committee will share the data with the Gender Equity Committee.

University Affairs Committee

Chair: Mary P. Mauldin

The University Affairs Committee comprising of Mary P. Mauldin (Chair), Kit Simpson, Sally Self, Terry OÍBrien, Janice Hundley, Luis Leite, Benjamin Saunders and Connie Best, dealt with important issues of continuity and communication.The Committee held an orientation for new Senators between 3 and 6 PM on Thursday, September 5. This orientation meeting was very well attended. She also mentioned about revamping the electoral process and incorporate the changes into our bylaws. Dr. Kilpatrick charged Francine Margolius as the veteran senator to facilitate the electoral process on our next meeting on October 1, 2002.

Faculty Affairs Committee

Chair: Subbi P. Mathur

Subbi P. Mathur applauded the efforts of her hard working committee members Philippe Arnaud, Dean Schuyler, Ramita Bonadonna, John Malley, Katherine Chessman, Peter Kobes, Joann Sullivan, Richard Hernandez and Timothy Carter. Together they organized two workshops, one for the Faculty Senate on Tenure Policy and the other for the General Faculty on Tenure and Mentoring. More importantly, they worked to revise the current Tenure Policy in the Faculty Handbook. The document incorporated comments from all senators and from the faculty senate legal counsel, and was presented in the form of a motion for voting. The Revised Tenure Policy was unanimously approved by the Faculty Senate, after a minor revision. {Details: The senators voted unanimously (in our previous meetings we had required a quorum only for passing the minutes, but a simple majority of those present was sufficient to pass a motion; Examples are: March 5 and May 7 meetings when we passed the revised Criminal Background Search, Conflict of Interest and Outside Activities Policies). Comments from the floor:

  • To make uniform Tenure requirements description. However, it was pointed out that these documents vary from college to college and are in the Appendix. Revision of the Appendix on Tenure Requirements can be taken up by the next year's Faculty Affairs Committee.
  • To change the line of command bypassing the Chair of the Department. However, this is not the standard practice.
  • To bring in "up or out" kind of action for granting tenure within a certain time period. This was not favorably received.
  • To mention non-college affiliated departments along with colleges, since some faculty members belong to a non-college affiliated department. This suggestion was accepted and the policy was revised accordingly. }

The presentation at the Faculty Forum will be done at the Chair's convenience. The next step will be for the Senate Chair to forward the Revised Tenure Policy to the Deans' Council.

IV. Policies under review

Outside Activities and Conflict of Interest Policies (originally approved by the Faculty Senate and subsequently revised by Dr. Valerie West) and Drug-free Workplace Policy will be discussed at future Senate meetings.

V. Caucusing

The Senators from the various Colleges grouped and caucused for electing their representatives for the oncoming election on October 1.

III. ADJOURNMENT

The meeting was adjourned at 9:30 AM.


Next meeting: 7:45 AM, Tuesday, October 1, 2002, Administration/Library Building Room 107.


Committee and Job Assignments

Governance Committee: Francine R. Margolius (Chair), Subbi P. Mathur, Nancy McKeehan, Janice Hundley, Joli Cerveny, Betsy Pilcher, Gail Pashek and Eberhard Voit

Faculty Affairs Committee: Subbi P. Mathur (Chair), Philippe Arnaud, Dean Schuyler, Ramita Bonadonna, John Malley, Katherine Chessman, Peter Kobes, Joann Sullivan, Richard Hernandez and Timothy Carter.

Academic Affairs Committee: Philippe Arnaud (Chair), Subbi P. Mathur, Barry Hainer, Paul Gold, Jennie Ariail, DeAnna Cheek, Joan Olson, Tara Hulsey, Gary Gilkeson and John Bosso. Indirect Costs Sub committee: Eberhard Voit (Chair), Gail Pashek, Narendra L. Banik, Kit Simpson, Paul Gold, Carlos Salinas and Susan Tate

University Affairs Committee: Mary P. Mauldin (Chair), Kit Simpson, Sally Self, Terry OÍBrien, Janice Hundley, Luis Leite, Benjamin Saunders, Connie Best and Janice Lage

Faculty Senate Retreat Coordinator: Subbi P. Mathur

Faculty Senate Workshop on Tenure and Mentoring for the General Faculty: Subbi P. Mathur

Webmaster: Mary P. Mauldin

Respectfully Submitted by:

Subbi P. Mathur
Secretary to the Faculty Senate